I Tried Made In’s Beloved $19 Baking Sheet — and Honestly, I’d Pay More For It

I Tried Made In’s Beloved $19 Baking Sheet — and Honestly, I’d Pay More For It
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
close up shot of assorted roasted veggies on a baking sheet.
Credit: Photo: Alex Lepe ; Food Stylist: Rachel Perlmutter

As both a home cook and baker, I rely heavily on my sheet pans. Sometimes I don’t want to break out the bigger one, though, because they’re quite bulky to clean in my sink. So instead, I picked up Made In’s Quarter Sheet Pan for the nights I’m making a quick side of veggies or just want to bake a few cookies instead of a whole batch. Not only is this pan the perfect size for situations like those, it’s also just $19. 

Someone holding up Made In sheet pan.
Credit: Micki Wagner

What You Should Know About Made In’s Quarter Sheet Pan

Made In Quarter Sheet Pan at Made In

Made from aluminum, it’s 9.5×13 inches and fits four or five hefty scoops of cookie dough (depending on how much they’ll spread in the oven). It’s hand-wash only, oven-safe up to 500°F, and has racked up rave reviews — 2,800 five-star reviews to be exact.

Cookies made on Made In sheet pan.
Credit: Micki Wagner

My Honest Review of Made In’s Quarter Sheet Pan

I often bake small batches of cookies and freeze the rest so I can have a fresh one out of the oven pretty much whenever I’d like. So, this sheet pan is the ideal size for me. Even the bottoms of my spice cookies were perfectly golden (I often come close to burning them). 

I’ve used this pan both with cooking spray and without, and I’ve found the cooking spray helps prevent the cookies from sticking, which I especially appreciate when it comes time for cleanup. 

I can already tell that this handy sheet pan is going to become a quick favorite in my kitchen. It’s the perfect size, high quality, and easy to clean. At only $19, it’ll also make a phenomenal gift for the holidays … just in case you’re shopping early.